Showing posts with label ALLEGHENY NATIONAL FOREST. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ALLEGHENY NATIONAL FOREST. Show all posts

Saturday, February 20, 2010

Forest Service wants judge to reverse Pa. ruling

timesleader.com
Friday, February 19, 2010

(AP) The U.S. Forest Service wants a federal judge in Erie to reverse his December ruling which temporarily lifted a ban on oil and gas well drilling in the Allegheny National Forest.

U.S. District Judge Sean McLaughlin's ruling says Forest Service officials were wrong to ban drilling in April until an environmental assessment could be done. The Forest Service agreed to the ban to settle litigation brought by environmentalists.

Meanwhile, oil and gas companies who stood to lose millions of dollars under the ban have asked the judge to make his December order permanent.

McLaughlin has scheduled arguments on both requests March 9.

LINK

See Splashdown December 18, 2009 post: Erie judge ends drilling ban in Allegheny National Forest: Forest Service can't dictate forest's mineral-rights development!

DEMAND ACCOUNTABILITY!

Monday, January 25, 2010

Forest Fragmentation and Natural Gas Development

PA Environment Digest
Daily Blog
January 24, 2010


Department of Conservation and Natural Resources Acting Secretary John Quigley told the Senate Environmental Resources and Energy Committee recently he was concerned thousands of new natural gas wells and thousands of miles of access roads and related collection pipelines could have a major impact on Pennsylvania's State Forests.
The fragmentation of forest habitats has also been a concern of environmental groups like Pennsylvania Audubon.
Until now it was hard to illustrate how natural gas and oil well development can affect a forest. Recently, however, the website Damascus Citizens circulated aerial photos of gas well sites from all over the country, including in Pennsylvania.
An aerial photo of traditional oil and gas well development in Forest County, Pa in a portion of the Allegheny National Forest just north of the Clear Creek State Forest clearly shows how roads and drilling pads can fragment a forest.
To see it for yourself, enter these coordinates in Google Earth-- 41 degrees, 30 minutes 47.77 seconds North, 79 degrees 11 minutes 16.13 seconds west.
Marcellus Shale well development patterns are different because they use fewer well pads by drilling very deep vertical wells and then drill horizontal wells out in several directions in the natural gas producing strata.
The aerial photo on Google Earth is part of the statewide series made available by the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources' PA Map Program, recently eliminated in this year's state budget.
LINK.
DEMAND ACCOUNTABILITY!

Friday, December 18, 2009

Erie judge ends drilling ban in Allegheny National Forest: Forest Service can't dictate forest's mineral-rights development

LISA THOMPSON
Erie Times-News
istockanalyst.com
Thursday, December 17, 2009

Forest Service reached a settlement with environmental groups in which the Forest Service agreed to subject future development of oil and gas wells to more thorough scrutiny under the 1970 National Environmental Policy Act.

Most of the national forest comprises what are known as "split estates." The surface of the land belongs to the federal government, while 93 percent of the subsurface -- the rights to valuable crude oil and natural gas beneath that forest -- is owned by private citizens.

Those whose livelihoods depend on the oil and gas rights in the 513,325-acre national forest asked McLaughlin to toss out the settlement and require the Forest Service to return the past practice of handling oil and gas-well proposals.

They predicted the Forest Service's review of oil- and gas-drilling plans would proceed at a creeping pace, wreaking financial ruin in an already economically distressed area.

In his ruling, McLaughlin agreed.

"There is substantial evidence that several oil and gas-related businesses that rely upon drilling in the Allegheny National Forest for their livelihood may be forced out of business," he wrote.

He said the Forest Service could meet its obligations to protect the surface of the forest without requiring stringent NEPA reviews of each project.

Fesenmyer said McLaughlin struck the right balance.

"We have always worked with the Forest Service in cooperation as good custodians of the land. At the same time, we were doing what we were legally entitled to do," he said.

LINK.

DEMAND ACCOUNTABILITY!

Thursday, December 10, 2009

UPDATE: Allegheny National Forest... Drilling case still pending

Bortz: ‘It might be ugly’

By DEAN WELLS dwells@timesobserver.com
Times Observer
Dec. 1o, 2009


A decision regarding drilling in the Allegheny National Forest is still pending in U.S. District Court and a Warren County Commissioner sees no resolution in the very near future.

An evidentiary hearing was held in August in U.S. District Court in Erie before Judge Sean McLaughlin regarding a preliminary injunction filed by Minard Run Oil, Pennsylvania Oil and Gas Association (POGAM), the Allegheny Forest Alliance and Warren County.
The plaintiffs are seeking a preliminary injunction against a settlement in a prior lawsuit that called for the U.S. Forest Service to agree to perform the appropriate level of National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) analysis before approving future oil and gas development projects on the National Forest.
Warren County joined the oil and gas interests in the lawsuit for an injunction, arguing that a moratorium on drilling will have a devastating impact on the local economy.
The defendants in the lawsuit are the Forest Service, the agency's local and national leaders, the Allegheny Defense Project, Forest Service Employees for Environmental Ethics and the Sierra Club.
McLaughlin heard testimony for three days at the end of August from the defendants in favor of dismissing the suit and the plaintiffs arguing in favor of a preliminary injunction. McLaughlin concluded the hearing by giving attorneys 20 days after the official transcript was released to file post-hearing submissions.

Warren County Commissioners John Bortz speculated in October that McLaughlin would make his decision by the end of the month, but that never happened. Now, Bortz doesn't foresee a decision being handed down in 2009.

"We were supposed to hear something before the end of the year," Bortz said. "I personally don't expect to see anything before the end of January."

While trying to remain optimistic, Bortz said he doesn't see a happy ending for the plaintiffs. "I don't think it's going to be good," he said. "It might be ugly."

Bortz added, "While I'm an ardent supporter of capitalizing on our natural assets, I do not support drilling at any cost or irresponsible activity in the forest. Those guys who are being responsible and respecting the forest, I don't have any problem with that. Those guys who are saying, 'I'm going to get what's coming to me, I don't care what the Forest Service says,' I don't agree with that at all."

LINK

DEMAND ACCOUNTABILITY!

Friday, October 30, 2009

Petition to continue oil and gas drilling on Allegheny National Forest sent to Obama, Rendell


A petition signed by 2,000 people in favor of continuing oil and gas drilling on the Allegheny National Forest has been sent to President Barack Obama and Pennsylvania Gov. Ed Rendell.

The petition, distributed by the Pennsylvania Oil and Gas Association (POGAM) and the Allegheny Forest Alliance, urges intervention to lift a ban on oil and gas development by the U.S. Forest Service.

The ban came earlier this year after a settlement between the Forest Service and a group of environmentalists who were seeking to have environmental impact analyses done prior to any drilling on the forest.

See Splashdown's "Oil and Gas Drilling is Transforming the Allegheny National Forest" and "Warren County Commissioner gathering evidence for oil/gas drilling hearing"

The settlement is a deviation from prior management practices, which never required an analysis. The Forest Service has ordered a halt to new drilling until a forest-wide impact assessment can be prepared.

The oil interests say that delay will be devastating to the local economy, as at least a year will pass without drilling and local companies are having to lay-off workers.

On Thursday, Steve Rhoads, president of POGAM, explained the reason behind the petition.



“The only way, outside of a court action, for this stop is if the Forest Service decides to stop or if someone above forces their hand. We don’t expect the Forest Service to back away from its policy. That’s why we’re in court,” he said. “They are shutting the industry down, period.”

“We wanted to demonstrate to the powers that be that the behavior of the Forest Service and the effects of that behavior is far reaching and very damaging,” Rhoads said, “not only to owners of minerals who are being stifled by the bureaucratic logjam this is creating, but the employees, families, and communities as well.
“The potential for layoffs is growing as the Forest Service shuts the industry down arbitrarily,” he said. “The economic ramifications are significant. We’re asking for some intercession on behalf of the communities to protect their economic interest and health.”

Nearly 2,000 citizens, and civic and business leaders from McKean, Elk, Warren and Forest counties signed the petition.

Meanwhile, a lawsuit is pending in federal court in which Minard Run Oil Co. of Bradford, along with POGAM, the Forest Alliance and Warren County, are awaiting a judge’s decision on whether to grant a preliminary injunction against the enforcement of the settlement order.

“We expect a decision on the preliminary injunction at any time now,” Rhoads said. “We don’t know what that decision will be. We’re hopeful for a positive result.”

He said this petition has nothing to do with any action in federal court.

The petition, on the other hand, is to bring attention to the suffering local oil industry at a time when the federal government is working on stimulating the economy and creating jobs.

“We want to bring attention to the issue at the highest level of governments,” Rhoads said.

“State records show that fewer than 50 wells, all of them permitted prior to the drilling ban imposed on January 1, have been drilled in the Allegheny National Forest during 2009. The Forest Service has prevented the drilling of between 200-300 wells that would have otherwise occurred,” Rhoads said. “These undrilled wells translate into private investment of nearly $100 million and jeopardize hundreds of good-paying jobs in the region. The action of the Forest Service amounts to a full-scale assault on the economic health of the families and communities living in and around the Allegheny National Forest.”
...

For the complete story, CLICK HERE.


DEMAND ACCOUNTABILITY!

Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Warren County Commissioner gathering evidence for oil/gas drilling hearing

By BRIAN FERRY bferry@timesobserver.com
TIMES OBSERVER, August 18, 2009

One side says the economic impacts are devastating.

The other side doesn't see it that way.

The judge in a case filed by representatives of the oil and gas industry against the U.S. Forest Service and environmental groups wants to hear the specifics of those economic impacts.

Warren County Commissioner John Bortz will be one of the witnesses testifying at an evidentiary hearing scheduled for Monday and Tuesday in federal court in Erie.

To prepare for that event, Bortz, with the help of Warren County Chamber of Business and Industry (WCCBI) Director of Workforce Development Heidi Powley, is gathering evidence.

...

Bortz did not disclose the results of the survey that had come in as of Monday, but gave a preliminary outline of the findings.

"There is a degree of confirmation" of negative effects on the economy, he said. "They are pointing to a direct impact from the moratorium on new development."

"This is having a direct effect on us locally," Bortz said.

Powley explained that she has been polling local businesses via email.

"I basically asked them how the ruling... has impacted their business," she said.

Those polled include all chamber members and various other business contacts in Warren, Forest, McKean and Elk counties, Powley said.

She did not disclose the results of the polling but said she has been getting responses.

In July, U.S. District Court Judge Sean McLaughlin scheduled the evidentiary hearing after a hearing to rule on a defense motion to dismiss the lawsuit and a plaintiff motion for a preliminary injunction against a prior settlement.

In that prior settlement, the Forest Service and plaintiffs Allegheny Defense Project (ADP), Forest Service Employees for Environmental Ethics (FSEEE), and the Sierra Club agreed that the appropriate level of National Environmental Policy Act analysis be done before new drilling development is allowed on the Allegheny National Forest.

The Forest Service agreed to allow several hundred new wells, for which applications were already in place, but to otherwise put a hold on new drilling until a forest-wide Environmental Impact Statement can be prepared. That process is expected to take at least a year.

In the current lawsuit, Minard Run Oil, Pennsylvania Oil and Gas Association (POGAM), Allegheny Forest Alliance (AFA) and Warren County are the plaintiffs and the Forest Service, the agency's local and national leaders, ADP, FSEEE, and Sierra Club are named as defendants.

CLICK HERE for article source.

DEMAND ACCOUNTABILITY!

Friday, August 14, 2009

Oil and Gas Drilling is Transforming the Allegheny National Forest

According to Alan Gregory's Conservation News, "The Allegheny is the most heavily drilled federal public land anywhere. It is a veritable pincushion of drill pads, storage tanks, roads, clearcuts, holding ponds and pollution." In 2007 the Allegheny Defense Project published this slideshow of aerial views of oil and gas drilling in the Allegheny National Forest in Pennsylvania. At that time, the ANF had approximately 9,000 active oil and gas wells... more than all other national forests combined! The Forest Service predicts that if current rates of drilling continue, there could be 20,000 wells by 2020 and an additional 3,000 miles of roads. According to the ADP, "The oil and gas industry, the Forest Service, and the PA DEP all share the blame for what is happening in Pennsylvania's only national forest."

DEMAND ACCOUNTABILITY!


RURAL IMPACT VIDEOS, 6 parts

Natural gas development in Colorado, the impacts on communities, environment and public health. A primer for public servants and residents of counties that care for their lifestyles.

Drilling for Gas in Bradford County, PA ... Listen!

Cattle Drinking Drilling Waste!

EPA... FDA... Hello? How many different ways are we going to have to eat this? ... Thank you TXSharon for all you do! ... Stay tuned in at http://txsharon.blogspot.com

Landfarms

A film by Txsharon. Thank you Sharon for all you do. Click HERE to read the complete article on Bluedaze: Landfarms: Spreading Toxic Drilling Waste on Farmland

SkyTruth: Upper Green River Valley - A View From Above